An employment contract, like any other contract, creates obligations for the parties to it, in this case employer and employee. When an employer fails to honour a contractual obligation, an employee may have a claim for breach of contract (and vice versa). There are two main routes for pursuing a claim for breach of contract, namely the Employment Tribunal (ET) and the civil courts. This article concerns employment contract claims in England and Wales.
Bringing a claim in the Employment Tribunal
The ET’s contractual jurisdiction is limited. An employee can bring a claim under this jurisdiction only once their employment has ended, and the claim must arise or be outstanding on termination. Termination need not be a dismissal by the employer and a claim may also follow resignation.
A common example is wrongful dismissal, a dismissal in breach of the employee’s contractual notice entitlement. This is different from unfair dismissal, which concerns statutory employment rights (as opposed to contractual rights).
Also, not all contractual disputes can be heard by the tribunal. Personal injury claims are excluded, as are claims concerning certain terms relating to accommodation, intellectual property, confidentiality and restraints of trade.
What is the deadline for the contractual claim in ET?
For employment ending on or after 1st October 2026, the ordinary deadline is six months less one day from the effective date of termination. The previous ordinary limit of three months less one day continues to apply where the relevant termination or last working day was before 1st October 2026.
Employees normally need to notify ACAS for Early Conciliation before presenting their claim. The Early Conciliation rules adjust the deadline, so the final date must be calculated using the relevant notification and certificate dates.
A late claim may be accepted only where the ET is satisfied that presenting it within the applicable time limit was not reasonably practicable and that it was then presented within a further reasonable period. This is a restricted exception.
How much can be recovered?
The ET can order payment of no more than £25,000 for a contractual claim, or several contractual claims relating to the same contract. Therefore, an employee should not pursue a contractual claim to judgment in the tribunal expecting to recover the balance above £25,000 in court afterwards. Case law confirms that ET judgments prevent a subsequent court claim for the excess on the same cause of action.
Can legal costs be recovered?
In the ET, each party generally pays its own legal costs, regardless of who wins. A successful employee should therefore not assume that the employer will reimburse their solicitor’s fees. However, costs orders are possible in specified circumstances, including unreasonable or vexatious conduct, a claim or response with no reasonable prospect of success, or non-compliance with procedural requirements. Recovery is therefore exceptional.
Unlawful deductions from wages
A claim for unlawful deductions from wages is a separate statutory claim, not a claim under the ET’s contractual jurisdiction. It may be brought by a qualifying worker, including an employee, while employment continues, therefore resignation or dismissal is not required. The £25,000 contractual cap does not apply to this statutory claim, although separate rules restrict how far back deductions can be recovered. The current ordinary presentation period is six months from the relevant deduction, or the last deduction in a series, subject to the applicable commencement provisions and ACAS Early Conciliation adjustments.
Bringing a claim in the civil courts
There is no requirement for employment to end.
A contractual claim can also be pursued in the civil courts, usually the County Court, with suitable higher value or complex cases proceeding in the High Court. Unlike the ET’s contractual jurisdiction, this route does not depend on employment having ended. An employee can pursue an existing contractual entitlement while remaining employed.
For example, a dispute about unpaid contractual remuneration need not wait until resignation or dismissal. However, the employee must establish the contractual obligation and explain how the employer has breached it.
What is the deadline?
For an ordinary claim founded on a simple contract, the limitation period is six years from the date the cause of action accrued, usually when the breach occurred. It does not automatically start when employment ends or when the employee discovers the breach but different unpaid instalments may have different limitation dates.
Is compensation unlimited?
There is no equivalent to the Employment Tribunal’s £25,000 contractual cap in the civil courts. A contractual claim worth more than that amount can therefore be pursued without that particular restriction.
However, “no statutory cap” does not mean “unlimited compensation”. An employee can recover sums contractually due or damages recoverable under the applicable legal principle. A claim for damages requires evidence of recoverable loss caused by the breach and the rules on remoteness and reasonable mitigation may restrict recovery.
In a straightforward wrongful dismissal case, damages will usually focus on the pay and contractual benefits lost during the notice period, subject to relevant deductions and the terms of the contract. However, court proceedings do not automatically entitle an employee to compensation for all future earnings or for the unfair manner of their dismissal.
Can legal costs be recovered?
In civil proceedings, costs recovery depends significantly on the track to which the claim is allocated:
a) Small claims track – solicitor’s fees are generally not recoverable from the other party. Limited items, such as court fees and certain attendance expenses, may be recovered. Further costs may be ordered for unreasonable behaviour.
b) Fast track and intermediate track, where the fixed recoverable costs regime applies, the recoverable legal costs are generally prescribed amounts, together with permitted disbursements, rather than the solicitor’s actual bill. The applicable stage and complexity band affect the amount.
c) Multi-track. The general rule is that the unsuccessful party pays the successful party’s costs, subject to the court’s discretion. Costs are ordinarily assessed for reasonableness and proportionality on the standard basis, so even a successful party may not recover their entire bill.
The possibility of recovering costs must therefore be balanced against the risk of having to contribute towards the employer’s costs if the claim fails and costs exposure should be considered alongside the value and merits of the claim before choosing a forum.
Choosing the right route
Therefore, before starting proceedings, an employee should consider:
a) Employment status and termination: is the ET’s contractual jurisdiction available at all?
b) Value: would the £25,000 ET cap prevent recovery of the full contractual claim?
c) Time limits: which deadline applies, and how does ACAS Early Conciliation affect it?
d) Other claims: does the dispute also involve statutory rights rather than breach of contract alone?
e) Previous proceedings: has the same contractual claim already been determined?
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal or professional advice. Please note that the law may have changed since this article was published.