It goes without saying that as a business owner, protecting your brand is essential. Your reputation is one of your most valuable assets, one that allows your business to grow, maintain customer trust, and remain competitive. But what happens when someone posts negative comments about your products or services? And what if that person is your employee?
When reputational damage comes from employees, the impact can be significantly more serious. Employees typically know the business well, meaning their criticism may appear more credible than that of a one‑off customer. Negative online behaviour by staff can also strain relationships between colleagues and undermine overall morale.
Can employers take action even when harmful content is posted outside of working hours?
First, let’s have a look at the internal policies. Employment Tribunal decisions in England and Wales consistently highlight that a robust, clearly worded social media policy (explicitly addressing reputational risk and disciplinary consequences) is key to enabling employers to respond effectively. In serious cases, this can include dismissal where an employee’s online conduct threatens the employer’s reputation. Whether such a dismissal is fair will depend not only on the content of the policy and how well it was communicated, but also on whether the employee’s conduct can reasonably be connected to the employer, and whether a fair process has been followed. A well‑drafted policy, communicated properly, may deter harmful behaviour and, if necessary, provide a solid basis for defending a claim at tribunal.
A leading example is a case of Mr C Whelan v Blue Triangle Buses Ltd: 3200787/2018, where the tribunal upheld dismissal for gross misconduct after an employee posted social media content linked to the employer that portrayed the company negatively. The employer’s social media policy was explicit: it warned that reputational harm, whether during working hours or in employees’ personal time, could result in disciplinary action up to and including summary dismissal. In that case, the employer not only had a social media policy stating that it takes the reputation of the company, customers, suppliers, and staff seriously, but also a disciplinary procedure requiring employees to exercise caution online and avoid posting anything connected with their employment that could offend or bring the company into disrepute.
As confirmed in Linda Trainer v Malhota Group plc T/a Prestwick Care: 2501569/2017 the key question is whether the misconduct affects the employment relationship or the employee’s ability to perform their role. Employers cannot normally discipline staff for what they do on their personal devices at home unless the conduct has the potential to damage the employer’s reputation. Social media, by its nature, makes this link easier to establish.
Is dismissal always the appropriate response?
Not necessarily. You need to follow fair and transparent procedure before taking action. This includes conducting a proper investigation, allowing the employee to present their case, and ensuring that the ultimate decision is proportionate.
Indeed, as highlighted in Mr P Jeffries v Stagecoach South East: 2306273/2020any disciplinary action must be proportionate and based on a careful assessment of all circumstances. The examples of questions you should ask yourself are: did your employee apologise? Was it an isolated incident or part of a pattern? What is the extent of reputational harm? Can the online activity be reasonably linked to your business? Tribunals will assess whether the employer acted within the “range of reasonable responses,” considering the seriousness of the misconduct, the employee’s role, and any mitigating factors.
What action can you take now to prevent reputational damage?
- Create a clear, comprehensive social media policy. Define unacceptable online behaviour. Address conduct both inside and outside the workplace. Specify that reputational harm may lead to disciplinary action, including dismissal.
- Ensure the policy is properly communicated. Provide the policy to all employees.
Discuss it during induction. Re‑circulate it periodically and remind staff of updates.
- Align the social media policy with disciplinary procedures. Ensure disciplinary policies clearly list reputational damage as potential misconduct. Maintain consistency between all internal policies and procedures.
- Train managers and staff. Offer training on responsible online behaviour and the consequences of social media misuse. Equip managers to identify risks early and respond appropriately. Explain why you need to protect your brand.
Case law clearly highlights that well‑drafted, well‑communicated social media policy is vital for employers seeking to safeguard their reputation and justify dismissal where necessary. Policies should set out expectations, explain the consequences of breaches, and be consistently enforced. Although dismissal can be fair where reputational harm is significant, each case depends on its specific facts which must be assessed before any decision is made.
Call us: 0330 107 0107
Email us: info@imd.co.uk
