Subscribe to our newsletter

Reading room

Resolving conflicts between shareholders and creditors

Posted by:
Posted in: Dispute resolution
Date published: 12/07/2023

As a business owner, it is essential to understand that conflicts between shareholders and creditors can arise anytime. These conflicts can significantly impact your company’s operations and lead to costly legal battles that can take years to resolve. In this article, we will discuss some insights and tips on resolving conflicts between shareholders and creditors, ensuring a harmonious working relationship and smooth business operations.

Understanding shareholder and creditor conflicts

Shareholders and creditors are critical stakeholders in any business. Shareholders own a portion of the company’s equity and expect a return on their investment. On the other hand, creditors lend money to the business and expect to be repaid with interest. The relationship between shareholders and creditors is a complex one that can sometimes result in conflicts.

Shareholder and creditor conflicts typically arise when there is a financial dispute, and the company cannot meet its financial obligations. For example, if a company is unable to repay its loans, the creditors may take legal action against the company, which can result in the company’s liquidation. In such cases, the shareholders may lose their investments, which can lead to conflicts between shareholders and creditors.

Types of shareholder and creditor conflicts

There are several types of shareholder and creditor conflicts that can arise in a business. One of the most common types of conflicts is when shareholders disagree on the direction of the company. For example, one shareholder may want to expand the business, while another shareholder may want to focus on improving profitability. Such disagreements can lead to conflicts between shareholders, which can impact the company’s operations.

Another type of conflict that can arise between shareholders and creditors is when there is a dispute over the company’s valuation. Shareholders may have different opinions on the company’s worth, which can lead to conflicts when the company is looking to raise capital or sell shares.

Consequences of unresolved conflicts

Unresolved conflicts between shareholders and creditors can have severe consequences for a business. If the conflicts are not resolved, they can lead to legal battles that can cost the company a lot of money. These legal battles can also be time-consuming, which can distract the company from its core operations. In some cases, unresolved conflicts can even lead to the liquidation of the company, resulting in the loss of jobs and investments.

Strategies for resolving conflicts

The first step in resolving conflicts between shareholders and creditors is to identify the root cause of the conflict. Once the root cause has been identified, it is essential to communicate with all parties involved and try to find a mutually beneficial solution. Here are some strategies that can help resolve conflicts between shareholders and creditors:

Mediation and arbitration as conflict resolution methods

Mediation and arbitration are two methods that can be used to resolve conflicts between shareholders and creditors. Mediation involves bringing in a neutral third party to help facilitate a discussion between the parties involved. The mediator helps the parties identify the issues and find a mutually beneficial solution.

Arbitration involves bringing in a neutral third party to make a binding decision on the issue. The arbitrator listens to both parties’ arguments and makes a decision that is legally binding. Arbitration is typically faster and less expensive than going to court.

Legal options for resolving conflicts

If mediation and arbitration do not work, the parties may need to consider legal action. Legal action should be taken as a last resort, as it can be expensive and time-consuming. However, sometimes legal action is necessary to protect the interests of the company and stakeholders.

Preventing conflicts before they arise

Preventing conflicts between shareholders and creditors is always better than resolving them. Here are some strategies that can help prevent conflicts before they arise:

Clear communication

Clear communication is key to preventing conflicts. Communicating with shareholders and creditors regularly and being transparent about the company’s financial situation is essential. Communicating with shareholders and creditors regularly can help prevent misunderstandings and disputes.

Written agreements

Written agreements can help prevent conflicts by setting clear expectations for all parties involved. For example, a shareholder agreement can outline the shareholders’ rights and responsibilities, and a loan agreement can outline the terms of the loan.

Regular reviews

Regular reviews of the company’s financial situation can help prevent conflicts by identifying potential issues before they arise. Regular reviews can also help the company make informed decisions about its future direction.

Contact our Dispute Resolution Lawyers

Resolving conflicts between shareholders and creditors is essential to maintaining a harmonious working relationship and smooth business operations. At IMD, our team of dispute resolution solicitors are well known in the industry for their proactive and commercially focused advice, which is targeted at helping you achieve the best possible outcome. To discuss your requirements, please contact Marcin Durlak on 0330 107 0106.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal or professional advice. Please note that the law may have changed since this article was published.

To find out more about our services, visit Dispute Resolution section of our website.

Call us now to discuss your case 0330 107 0106 or email us at business@imd.co.uk.

Published by:

Marcin DurlakManaging Partner

Business Services – IMD Corporate

Awards and Accreditations