Reading room

Why Russian Clients Remain Valuable to Western Industries Despite Sanctions: The Overlooked Risks of the Information Secrecy and Anti-Sanctions Regimes

Posted by:
Posted in: Commercial solutions
Date published: 30/10/2024

Get in touch with our corporate lawyers in the UK and call us on 0330 107 0106 to arrange a free no no-obligation call or request a free quote.

Despite the ongoing geopolitical tensions and the sanctions imposed on Russia, many Russian clients continue to be valuable for Western industries such as the financial sector, legal services, and wealth management. These sectors have traditionally maintained strong relationships with high-net-worth individuals and corporations in Russia. However, Russia’s Information Secrecy Regime (ISR) and Counter-Sanctions Information Regime (CSIR) pose new challenges that many compliance specialists may overlook. These regimes are designed to protect sensitive data and shield certain transactions from international scrutiny, potentially allowing sanctioned individuals or entities to “slip through the net.”

Understanding the nuances of these regimes is critical for compliance officers and firms wishing to continue working with Russian clients while avoiding the risks of inadvertently violating sanctions.

The Value of Russian Clients for Western Industries

Despite the restrictions imposed by sanctions, Russian clients—especially those in the ultra-high-net-worth (UHNW) category—remain a cornerstone for Western industries like finance, legal, and wealth advisory services. Many Russian clients seek access to Western financial systems, legal expertise, and wealth management strategies to safeguard their assets and navigate increasingly complex regulatory landscapes.

Wealthy Russian individuals and businesses are particularly attracted to Western markets due to the higher levels of security, investment opportunities, and expertise they offer. For Western companies, these clients represent a significant revenue stream. However, the ISR and CSIR, coupled with sanctions, create both opportunities and risks.

The Role of the Information Secrecy Regime (ISR) and Counter-Sanctions Information Regime (CSIR)

Russia’s ISR and CSIR are designed to protect sensitive economic, military, and corporate information from external scrutiny. The **ISR** involves the classification of once-public data, fragmenting access to essential information such as ownership structures and financial transactions. The **CSIR**, meanwhile, allows Russian entities involved in foreign trade to withhold details about certain transactions that could expose them to sanctions.

These regimes are crafted to shield Russian businesses from the impact of foreign sanctions by reducing transparency. While these measures help protect Russian economic interests, they pose significant challenges for Western companies trying to comply with sanctions regimes.

The Compliance Blind Spot: How Russian Clients Can “Slip Through the Net”

Many compliance specialists may not be fully aware of the intricacies of the ISR and CSIR, and this could create vulnerabilities for Western companies. Given that the CSIR allows for the concealment of certain transaction details, companies and individuals subject to sanctions could evade detection by exploiting these secrecy measures.

For instance:

  • Closed-end mutual investment funds (CEIFs): Russian entities can conceal ownership details through CEIFs, allowing sanctioned individuals to maintain their assets without drawing scrutiny. This tactic has been used by some of Russia’s largest financial institutions.
  • Fragmentation of statistical and financial data: The ISR makes it difficult for compliance officers to verify information related to a company’s ownership or financial activities, particularly when dealing with state-owned enterprises or businesses operating in sensitive industries like defense and telecommunications.
  • Shielded transaction: The CSIR permits companies to withhold information about foreign trade transactions, potentially obscuring business dealings that should be flagged for sanctions compliance.

The Risk to Western Firms

The risk to Western firms, particularly those in financial services, legal consulting, and wealth management, is significant. Failure to identify and block transactions involving sanctioned entities can lead to severe penalties, both financial and reputational. Many compliance departments, especially those without deep expertise in Russian regulations, may struggle to effectively navigate the secrecy measures in place under ISR and CSIR.

This creates a scenario where firms may inadvertently provide services to Russian clients who are involved in activities that violate sanctions, or who are affiliated with individuals or entities on the sanctions list.

How Western Industries Can Adapt to These Challenges

To continue capitalizing on the lucrative Russian client market while mitigating compliance risks, Western firms must adopt more sophisticated strategies.

  1. Strengthening Compliance Programs: Companies need to upgrade their compliance systems by incorporating advanced investigative techniques. This includes using open-source intelligence (OSINT) and human intelligence (HUMINT) to identify indirect links between sanctioned entities and Russian clients who may be utilizing secrecy measures.
  2. Investing in Specialized Expertise: Compliance officers should be trained on the intricacies of the ISR and CSIR to better understand how these regimes impact the availability and reliability of information. Engaging legal experts familiar with Russian secrecy laws can help identify potential red flags that would otherwise go unnoticed.
  3. Leveraging Third-Party Due Diligence Providers: Working with external due diligence firms that specialize in high-risk jurisdictions like Russia can provide an added layer of security. These firms often have access to proprietary databases and investigative tools that can help uncover hidden relationships and financial flows that might be obscured by the ISR.
  4. Implementing AI-Powered Solutions: Artificial intelligence and machine learning tools can be used to monitor transactions and identify suspicious patterns that might indicate efforts to evade sanctions through concealed ownership or fragmented data.
  5. Developing Risk-Based Approaches: Not every Russian client presents the same level of risk. By implementing a risk-based approach to compliance, Western firms can focus their resources on high-risk clients while maintaining relationships with lower-risk individuals and entities. This ensures compliance without unnecessarily severing valuable business ties.

Russian Clients Are Still Valuable, But Caution Is Needed

Russian clients, particularly in the financial, legal, and wealth management sectors, remain valuable assets for many Western industries. However, the Information Secrecy Regime (ISR) and Counter-Sanctions Information Regime (CSIR) introduce significant risks for compliance specialists. These regimes allow certain Russian entities and individuals to conceal their activities, making it easier for them to slip through the net of sanctions enforcement.

To mitigate these risks, Western firms must enhance their compliance programs, invest in expertise, and adopt advanced technologies. By doing so, they can continue to serve Russian clients while avoiding the pitfalls of inadvertently facilitating activities that violate international sanctions. Firms that fail to adapt to these new realities risk facing severe financial and legal consequences, potentially damaging their reputation and bottom line in the process.

How a Law Firm Can Help Clients Navigate Russia’s Information Secrecy Regime

The Information Secrecy Regime (ISR) and Counter-Sanctions Information Regime (CSIR) in Russia impose stringent restrictions on the access and dissemination of information, especially in sectors crucial to national security and economic interests. With Russia increasingly prioritizing the concealment of sensitive data, businesses and individuals operating in the Russian market face unique obstacles, such as navigating restricted access to information, complying with secrecy laws, and safeguarding corporate data from sanctions risks.

For clients encountering these issues, law firms like IMD Solicitors, specializing in financial regulation, compliance, and information security, offer vital support. Here’s how a firm like IMD Solicitors can assist:

1. Preventing Information Leaks

Russia’s secrecy laws require companies to protect trade secrets, confidential data, and even the identities of owners in sensitive sectors. Leaking such information—either accidentally or deliberately—can lead to severe legal repercussions, including foreign-imposed sanctions.

IMD Solicitors can:

  • Conduct comprehensive risk assessments to identify weak points in a company’s data management practices.
  • Advise on compliance with Russian regulations governing the protection of sensitive corporate information and trade secrets.
  • Develop and implement robust internal policies for employees and third parties to ensure the safe handling and storage of confidential data.

2. Understanding the Counter-Sanctions Information Regime (CSIR)

The CSIR framework allows Russian companies to withhold foreign trade transaction details that could trigger foreign sanctions. However, it’s not always clear which information falls under this regime, leaving companies vulnerable to regulatory or media scrutiny.

IMD Solicitors can:

  • Interpret CSIR rules to help businesses understand what can legally be withheld from disclosure.
  • Assist in drafting legally sound contracts that include protective clauses to avoid unintended data leaks.
  • Liaise with regulatory bodies to ensure compliance with both Russian and international laws when handling foreign trade information.

3. Ensuring Compliance with Secrecy Regulations

Russia’s ISR encompasses more than just commercial secrets—it covers a wide array of classified data, including state secrets and military expenditures. Companies in sectors like defense, energy, and telecommunications must navigate strict secrecy regulations or risk severe penalties.

IMD Solicitors can:

  • Help businesses navigate complex secrecy requirements to ensure full compliance with Russian legal obligations.
  • Develop data security protocols that align with both corporate needs and the demands of the ISR.
  • Prepare crisis response plans to mitigate the fallout of any breach of secrecy laws or accidental disclosures.

4. Handling Cross-Border Transactions

As international scrutiny increases, cross-border transactions have become increasingly complicated, particularly for companies with ties to Russian businesses. The ISR further restricts the availability of information needed for compliance and transaction completion.

IMD Solicitors can:

  • Advise on structuring cross-border payments and transactions in line with both Russian secrecy laws and international financial regulations.
  • Mitigate risks associated with foreign payments by ensuring all sensitive information is protected.
  • Conduct due diligence for international investors seeking to engage in Russian markets, ensuring compliance with secrecy and sanctions rules.

Protecting Against Sanctions Threats

Foreign sanctions targeting Russian entities are an ever-present concern for companies operating within Russia. Legal firms with expertise in sanctions law provide critical guidance on how to reduce the likelihood and impact of sanctions.

IMD Solicitors can:

  • Identify potential sanctions risks related to a client’s business activities and recommend strategies to mitigate them.
  • Structure defensive measures such as utilizing closed-end mutual funds (CEIFs) to shield ownership structures and minimize exposure.
  • Advise on legal negotiations with foreign authorities to resolve sanctions issues and maintain business continuity.

Guidance on Public Procurement and Government Contracts

In Russia, government contracts in key sectors like defense and infrastructure are subject to strict secrecy. This includes concealing information about suppliers and adhering to classified budget requirements, posing additional hurdles for businesses.

IMD Solicitors can:

  • Guide companies through the public procurement process, ensuring full compliance with Russian secrecy laws while fulfilling contractual duties.
  • Structure government contracts to protect sensitive data while avoiding sanctions risks when foreign parties are involved.
  • Advise on handling classified budgetary items to ensure regulatory compliance while safeguarding company interests.

Conclusion: How IMD Solicitors Can Help Overcome Secrecy Challenges

Operating within Russia’s Information Secrecy Regime presents significant challenges, from managing the complexities of regulatory compliance to protecting sensitive data from sanctions risks. Law firms like IMD Solicitors are essential in helping businesses and individuals navigate these difficulties.

With expertise in financial regulation, compliance, and legal risk management, IMD Solicitors offers tailored solutions that allow clients to remain compliant with Russian secrecy laws while safeguarding their corporate interests. From providing legal representation and advice to strategic risk management, IMD Solicitors empowers clients to successfully navigate the challenges posed by the ISR and CSIR, ensuring they can operate effectively in a highly secretive and regulated environment.

About the author

Janina White is an exceptionally qualified legal professional, uniquely positioned to provide specialized services in navigating the complexities of Russia’s Information Secrecy Regime (ISR) and Counter-Sanctions Information Regime (CSIR). As a dual-qualified solicitor in both England and Wales, as well as the Republic of Ireland, Janina brings a wealth of legal expertise combined with an advanced investigative skill set. She is a member of the prestigious Association of British Investigators and employs cutting-edge techniques like Open Source Intelligence (OSINT), Human Intelligence (HUMINT), and artificial intelligence to conduct thorough investigations. This combination of legal acumen and investigative precision allows her to offer tailored solutions that ensure full compliance with both Russian and international secrecy and sanctions laws.

Her deep understanding of financial regulation, compliance, and corporate governance is underpinned by her multilingual capabilities, including fluency in Russian, which enables her to seamlessly handle cross-border cases and sensitive matters involving Russian clients. As a STEP-qualified adviser, she is also well-versed in trust and estate management, making her an ideal expert for high-net-worth individuals and businesses requiring asset protection and confidentiality in international financial transactions. Janina’s track record of success in navigating complex regulatory environments and safeguarding sensitive information makes her the perfect choice for clients seeking to mitigate risks while maintaining valuable business relationships with Russian entities.

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal or professional advice. Please note that the law may have changed since this article was published.

To find out more about our services, visit Commercial Solutions section of our website.

Call us now to discuss your case 0330 107 0106 or email us at business@imd.co.uk.

Published by:

Janina WhiteConsultant

Business Services – IMD Corporate

Awards and Accreditations